What are the opening hours?

Monday 9:30am - 5:30pm Tuesday 9:30am - 5:30pm Wednesday 9:30am - 5:30pm Thursday 9:30am - 5:30pm Friday 9:30am - 5:30pm

J. Anthony Jewelers

Name: J. Anthony Jewelers
Address: 220 S Commercial Street, Neenah, WI, 54956, US
Telephone: +19207291642

Home
United States
Neenah, WI
J. Anthony Jewelers

Neenah's Trusted Family Jeweler for Diamonds, Engagement Rings, Fine Jewelry and Repair, Since 1987 Started on a kitchen table in 1982, J. Be Fair, Be Creative.

Anthony's is now a 2nd generation family business that has been serving it's home community of Neenah and the Fox Cities since 1987 with it's retail storefront. We specialize in Custom Jewelry Design, designer jewelry, and repairs of all kinds. Treat others as you wish to be treated. Have Fun. Color outside of the lines. Be Unique. These are just some of the principles of J. Anthony Jewelers. Do y

ou have a need for diamond? We love diamonds and our passion for them shows through every time we talk to someone about diamonds. We hope our enthusiasm gets you excited about celebrating the moments in your life with fine jewelry and diamonds. Stop in anytime and share your thoughts with us and let's work together to get a diamond or gemstone that is nothing less than perfect for the occasion! Do you have old gold, silver, or platinum that you want to remodel? We can do that! Would you rather cash out on your precious metals? We can do that too, fast and easy anytime we are open.

05/22/2026

Honoring the true meaning of the long weekend✨

As we head into Memorial Day weekend, all of us at J. Anthony Jewelers want to take a moment to remember and honor the brave men and women who made the ultimate sacrifice for our country. We are profoundly grateful for the freedoms we enjoy every day.

We will be closed on Monday, May 25th. We’ll be right back behind the counter on Tuesday morning at 930a, refreshed and ready to go. We hope you all have a safe, wonderful long weekend filled with good weather, family time, and maybe a local grill-out!

If you need a last-minute gift or repair pickup, stop in and see us before 530p today! Otherwise, we’ll see you bright and early on Tuesday.

Thank you for continuing to support our family business.

05/21/2026

The May Rush is real Neenah. 🏃‍♂️💨

Everyone knows December is our craziest month, but May always gives it a serious run for its money. Right now behind the counter, we are wrapping up packages for some of the biggest milestones a family can celebrate.

🎓 The Graduation Gem: A stunning piece to mark the end of one chapter and the beginning of the next. There is nothing like timeless jewelry to say "I'm proud of you."
✨ The Wrapped Masterpiece: A major milestone surprise, completely taken care of from the custom design to the final gold bow.
💎 The Anniversary Essentials: Classic diamond studs that never go out of style

Whatever you are celebrating before the holiday weekend hits, let us help you wrap up something unforgettable. We have the cases curated, the gift wrap ready, and the coffee hot.

What big milestone is your family checking off the list this month? 👇

We're here for you 930-530 Monday through Friday.

"Diamonds & Gems That Rock, Down By The Clock"

04/22/2026

People often comment that J. Anthony Jewelers is open Monday through Friday. In a retail world that never sleeps, that was a very deliberate choice.... no weekends 48 weeks of the year.

My degree in Operations Management from UW-Oshkosh taught me that efficiency isn't just about "doing things faster"—it’s about doing things BETTER so you can protect what matters most. For me, that’s my family and my time.

I obsess over my store operations, inventory and customers so that when 5:30pm hits, I can switch to Husband and Dad. Whether it’s a volleyball game, a softball tournament, baseball field, concert or family vacation, I do everything in my power to be there for my wife & kids and my team here.

That same drive for local impact is why I serve on our community boards. Whether it’s the Bergstrom-Mahler Museum of Glass , a world-class asset right here in our backyard—or the Neenah BID Board, where it’s all about keeping our downtown Neenah business district thriving, I’m committed to making Neenah a better place to live and work.

I believe you get the best version of us when my team and I are refreshed and focused. We work hard all week to provide you with the integrity and craft you deserve, so we can spend our weekends the same way you do: cheering on our kids and enjoying this community we call home.

Thanks for supporting a business that values family as much as you do.

~ Ben Ziemba

We're here for you 930-530 Monday through Friday.

"Diamonds & Gems That Rock, Down By The Clock"

04/15/2026

Sometimes, the masterpiece is already waiting for you. ✨

At J. Anthony Jewelers, we love the "dirt under the fingernails" work of custom design. However, I also know that not every "perfect" piece has to start from scratch.

Part of my job as your jeweler is traveling and sourcing collections that meet the same high standards for integrity and craftsmanship that I’d put into a custom build myself. That’s why I’m so proud to carry Allison Kaufman for over 16 years now.

Last week many new pieces arrived from my show order in early March that are, quite simply, beautifully designed from the start. They offer that high-end, custom-level feel without the wait of a from-scratch build. This week a few more arrived and here is a glimpse 😍

If you’re looking for something spectacular that’s ready to wear home today, come see these new arrivals. They’re proof that sometimes, the "perfect" piece is already right here in our showroom.

~ Benjamin ~

We're here for you 930-530 Monday through Friday.

"Diamonds & Gems That Rock, Down By The Clock"

04/10/2026

Custom-level quality. Ready today. 💍

At J. Anthony Jewelers, we are incredibly picky about what makes it into our cases. If a piece isn’t custom-crafted at our bench, it has to be designed and manufactured by someone who shares our obsession with perfection.

Enter our newest arrivals from Allison Kaufman. While I love the "soul" of a hand-forged custom piece, there is a different kind of beauty in the perfection of high-end manufacturing. We've curated 19 new pieces that showcase precision-set diamonds and intricate gold work that is crisp and built to last. It’s the kind of technical excellence that matches the standards my parents set in 1987.

We’ve curated this collection for the guest who wants a one-of-a-kind look with the flawless finish of a premier designer. Swipe through to see the detail on these new arrivals!

Which one is calling your name? 💎

We're here for you 930-530 Monday through Friday.

"Diamonds & Gems That Rock, Down By The Clock"

03/31/2026

Most of the time, the color you see in gems is enhanced through heat treatment. But what happens when you find a stone that’s perfect exactly the way it is?

We just delivered this custom creation featuring a spectacular Natural, un-heated Aquamarine, 6.56cts certified.

When an aquamarine is un-heated, you get this stunning, "crisp" ocean color that is rare to find. Sourcing a stone of this quality and size is the definition of "one-of-a-kind." We hand-crafted this setting specifically to showcase that crystal-clear stone, because sometimes nature doesn't need any help.

As a second-generation jeweler with over 20 years at the bench and showroom, I find satisfaction in letting these unique gems speak for themselves. This amazing custom piece has already found it's new home and we promised not to share it until it was claimed.

We're here for you 930-530 Monday through Friday.

"Diamonds & Gems That Rock, Down By The Clock"

03/16/2026

We're joining in on the closures for Monday. Stay safe everyone and don't overdue it when you start clearing the snow.

See you Tuesday weather willing.

02/23/2026

From Vacation Find to Everyday Favorite 🌵✨

While vacationing out west this past summer, one of our guests fell in love with this stunning Sleeping Beauty Turquoise. The only problem? It was set in yellow gold and felt a little too "high-profile" for her daily wear.

She knew exactly where to bring it once she got back to Neenah.

We took that vibrant gem and reimagined it in her favorite 14K Rose Gold, custom-crafting a mounting with a lower gallery. The result? A ring that sits comfortably, looks modern, and honors the memory of her trip.

Got a stone sitting in a drawer (or a mounting you don’t love)? Let’s talk about a "remodel" of your own.

We're here for you 930-530 Monday through Friday.

"Diamonds & Gems That Rock, Down By The Clock"

02/13/2026

💎Diamond solitaire studs make the most wonderful gift for Valentines. Zero calories, zero carbs, and they last way longer😅 They add some serious sizzle🔥 however. We're fully stocked with studs from 1/10ct up to 3ctw in naturals diamond and 4ctws in lab diamond.

Already have some studs from us? That's okay, it's time to trade up! Ask us for more details.

We're here for you 930-530 Monday through Friday.

"Diamonds & Gems That Rock, Down By The Clock"

02/11/2026

There is something special about a natural Emerald that you just can't fake. We recently finished this custom commission, featuring a vibrant natural center stone surrounded by an array of diamonds in rich, regal yellow gold.

This isn't just jewelry; it's a future heirloom. If you have a vision, let’s build it. We've been creating true custom heirlooms in Neenah since 1987.

We're here for you 930-530 Monday through Friday.

"Diamonds & Gems That Rock, Down By The Clock"

Address

220 S Commercial Street
Neenah, WI
54956

Opening Hours

Monday	9:30am - 5:30pm
Tuesday	9:30am - 5:30pm
Wednesday	9:30am - 5:30pm
Thursday	9:30am - 5:30pm
Friday	9:30am - 5:30pm

Telephone

+19207291642

Website

http://www.janthonyjewelers.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when J. Anthony Jewelers posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Address
Telephone
Opening Hours
Alerts
Contact The Business
Claim ownership or report listing

Want your business to be the top-listed Jewelery/watch Store in Neenah?