Silver in the City

Silver in the City Purveyors of jewelry, gifts and whatnot. We’re a locally-owned small business. Currently offering online ordering at silverinthecity.com
(634)

We are a small, locally-owned shop with a big heart and desire to make your day awesome! Voted Indy's Best Local Gift Shop for the past 9 years - we work hard to share fun, unique items with everyone - helping you find great gifts at all prices. Established in 2000 on a street called Mass Ave, in a town named Indy, by a gal named Kristin.

It’s almost Race Day! 🏁Stop into our Mass Ave Indy or Main Street Carmel stores to grab some Indy 500 merch this weekend...
05/22/2026

It’s almost Race Day! 🏁

Stop into our Mass Ave Indy or Main Street Carmel stores to grab some Indy 500 merch this weekend while you still can, or shop online at silverinthecity.com!

Our front window at our Mass Ave store recently got a glow up thanks to our amazingly talented employee, Natalie (.jpg) ...
05/15/2026

Our front window at our Mass Ave store recently got a glow up thanks to our amazingly talented employee, Natalie (.jpg) ✨

Stop by the see it for yourself this weekend!

Treat yourself to a new bag featuring a bold print or sage green stripes! ✨ 🛍️ Stop by our Mass Ave Indy or Main Street ...
05/12/2026

Treat yourself to a new bag featuring a bold print or sage green stripes! ✨

🛍️ Stop by our Mass Ave Indy or Main Street Carmel stores today, or shop online via link in bio!

05/11/2026

Just our professional opinion…

05/08/2026

Mother’s Day is this Sunday! 💝

If you still need a gift for your mom (or the mother figures in your life), you’re in luck! From silly to sentimental, we’ve got all kinds of gifts to show how much you care.

🛍️ Stop into our Mass Ave Indy or Main Street Carmel stores today, or browse online at silverinthecity.com

05/07/2026

Sometimes a silly little gift is the perfect remedy ✨

05/04/2026

Need a local or Indiana-themed gift for a loved one, client, or colleague?

Hop on over to our Mass Ave Indy or Main Street Carmel locations to browse our collection of Hoosier themed gifts and jewelry!

New products are here! ✨ Treat your mom to one of these candles and know you’ll be getting her something she’ll love. 🛍...
04/30/2026

New products are here! ✨

Treat your mom to one of these candles and know you’ll be getting her something she’ll love.

🛍️ Drop into our Mass Ave Indy or Main Street Carmel shops to snag one before they’re gone!

04/28/2026

Are you pickin’ up what we’re puttin’ down? 👀
🛍️ is open 7 days a week for all your jewelry, quirky, political, and whimsical gift buying needs!

Spoiler alert: IT’S YOU! 😉 Drop into this week and treat yourself to that item you’ve been eyeing.
04/27/2026

Spoiler alert: IT’S YOU! 😉

Drop into this week and treat yourself to that item you’ve been eyeing.

Address

434 Massachusetts Avenue
Indianapolis, IN
46204

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 8pm
Tuesday 10am - 8pm
Wednesday 10am - 8pm
Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm
Sunday 10am - 6pm

Telephone

+13179559925

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Silver in the City posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Silver in the City:

Shortcuts

Share

Category